Development of Implantable Medical Devices: From an Engineering Perspective

Article information

Abstract

INTRODUCTION

A medical device is defined as implantable if it is either partly or totally introduced, surgically or medically, into the human body and is intended to remain there after the procedure [1-2]. Jiang and Zhou [3] have described that 8% to 10% of the population in America and 5% to 6% of people in industrialized countries have experienced an implantable medical device for rebuilding body functions, achieving a better quality of life, or expanding longevity.

In the past six decades, implantable medical devices or systems have been advanced through developments in science and engineering, especially in microelectronics, biotechnology, and materials. From Zoll's first report [4] on electrical heart stimulation in 1952 to the first commercialized wireless blood pressure measurement system introduced by Cardiomems in 2010, medical experts have exerted honorable efforts to improve the quality of patients' lives with various medical devices, such as the implantable cardiac defibrillator, cochlear implant, implanted bladder stimulator, and implantable wireless pressure sensor [5-17]. Such implantable medical devices were developed to sense a physiological response in vivo or to actuate physiological organs. Recently, with the superminiaturization of electronic circuits and mechanical structures, many researchers have focused on the development of implantable real-time vital monitoring systems, which are continuously operated in subsecond periods [18-21]. The implantable real-time vital monitoring devices may shift medical systems from remedying incidents after they occur to self-managing incidents before they occur. For example, the EndoSure of Cardiomems, which is inserted into the aorta to measure intrasac pressure during endovascular abdominal aortic aneurysm repair and during endovascular thoracic aortic aneurysm repair, can detect intraoperative leaks of the stent graft. After discharge from the hospital, patients can check the intrasac pressure daily at home, which was traditionally monitored by an angiographic method only at a hospital [22].

The first fully implantable pacemaker was encapsulated by araldite epoxy resin. In the polymer encapsulation, a low power consumption first-generation silicon transistor (OC460) integrated with electrical circuits was packaged with two sealed 60 mAh nickel-cadmium battery cells. The electrical circuit was connected with an inductive coil for recharging the batteries. The electrical-pulse-generating system was connected with electrodes via stainless steel wire covered with polyethylene. The total size of the first implantable pacemaker was 55 mm in diameter and 16 mm in thickness, similar to the dimensions of a shoe polish can from British Kiwi [10].

From the old machine, we could read the engineer's intentions to develop the most valuable device for human beings. In the early stages of the silicon-based transistor, the semiconductor technology was not high-tech enough to handle micron-level sizes. After metal-oxide-semiconductor field-effect-transistor was invented, the shrinkage race for transistor size was initiated with the spreading of cleanroom facilities in the 1960s. In 1971, Intel had adopted a 10-µm manufacturing technology, and in 2012, the company applied a 22-nm line width technology on the Xeon E3-1230 [23-25]. The 22-nm node technology can produce approximately 500 transistors on an area, which is occupied by a 10-µm node transistor. Through advancements in semiconductor technology, smaller, lighter, and multipurpose electronic devices became available. Diminishment in the electronic circuit resulted in other advantages in battery lifetime and capacity [26]. In 1973, Greatbatch and Holmes [5] developed lithium-iodine batteries, which have good characteristics for use in the smaller and lighter electronic systems, such as a long lifetime, low current drain, and static voltage output. In the early era of pacemaker implants, artificial heart pulses were transferred to the myocardium via a stainless steel lead. On October 9, 1958, the Swedish physician Senning (quoted from [7]) implanted a second pacemaker unit that functioned well for only 7 days. Suddenly, the amplitude of the pacemaker stimulus was gradually decreased by a fracture in the stainless steel lead. After figuring out the inferior mechanical and chemical properties of stainless steel in the human body, many researchers attempted to replace the lead configuration with different materials, such as alloys of cobalt, chromium, and nickel [7]. However, those old-generation pacemaker leads had limitations such as high fracture rates, dislodgement, electromagnetic interference, high capture thresholds, and corrosion [27]. The lead-related issues were finally solved by the use of materials such as silicone or polyurethane-insulated noble metal coils of platinum and iridium or titanium [8].

The epoxy resin encapsulation of the first-generation pacemaker was developed to protect the electronic circuits and batteries from body fluid penetration and tissue invasion to the system. Also, the encapsulation or housing worked as a barrier between the human body and hazardous batteries. However, the polymer-based epoxy resin swelled and dissolved inside the human body [28-30]. Thus, the housing materials had to be replaced with ceramics and titanium to protect the electrical systems. Currently, the electric elements and a battery are packaged by a laser welding of titanium, which has a strong mechanical hardness, extreme resistance to corrosion, biocompatibility, and durability [31,32]. Electrical connections between the metal-housed electronic system and the lead wire of the pacemaker induced another sealing issue. Owing to the metallic housing, the electrical signal output part, which is connected to the lead, should be passivated by an insulator to prevent electrical connection to the metal housing. Therefore, polymer- or ceramic-based electrical feedthrough was developed with perfect separation between the electronic system and the human body environment.

The first operation for implanting a pacemaker was done by the surgeon Ake Senning, who performed an open thoracotomy and suturing of 9-mm diameter electrodes on the left side of the myocardium. Afterward, the heart pace was electrically controlled for 3 hours. The next operation happened on following day and the device worked for 7 days. Currently, the pacemaker implant procedure takes around 1 to 2 hours with 4- to 5-mm diameter electrodes fixed on the right ventricle and the right atrium. One day after the operation, the patient is released from the hospital and can enjoy his or her regular life again with the help of the pacemaker. The small size and lightweight main body of the pacemaker allow the patient to avoid open-heart surgery, and the flexible platinum lead coils make an easy and short procedure possible [7].

Through this rough comparison between first-generation and modern pacemakers, the progress of the iconic implantable medical device was reviewed with an engineering mind. More detailed engineering considerations in the development of implantable medical devices will be described in the following sections.

GENERAL THOUGHTS ON IMPLANTABLE MEDICAL DEVICES

The designing of an implantable medical device is initiated with information gathering from three main participants: the patient, the medical staff, and the engineer. That is, the development of the device is highly influenced by the demands of patients, the preferences of medical doctors, and the realistic feasibility of the design as envisioned by the engineer. In general, patients who are in possession of a device either temporarily or permanently feel discomfort owing to the foreign object and have the expectation that the medical procedure be performed quickly without pain and that the healing procedure be accomplished unconsciously. Many efforts are needed to resolve these issues. Through the advent of minimally invasive medical procedures and the advanced shrinkage of the devices, the insertion site has become unnoticeable and restoration can occur unconsciously. A high-power-density battery made of lithium-iodine polyvinylpyridine, lithium-carbon monofluoride, or lithium-polycarbon fluoride gives a longer device-replacement interval to the patient [33-35]. After the implantation, programmed or designed functions of the devices work automatically. Consumers of the devices want to know whether the device is working properly, and they like to check the results of the device functioning without any special medical treatment, such as magnetic resonance imaging, computed tomography, or X-ray. Thus, the easy operation procedure, less invasive implantation, better healing performance, longer replacement timetable, and easy access to vital status results in a better quality of life of the consumers.

The medical doctor is a user, a reviewer, and a researcher of medical devices. Physicians need to know how to implant, where to implant, when to implant, and why to implant. They have heard many pathetic cases from patients and have met unexpected surgical situations owing to the different structure of the human body. Fortunately, they have studied the structure, elements, and function of the human body. They are often the ones to propose an initial design concept to the patient and engineer. The size and shape of the medical device should be considered to fit the implantation spot in the human body. If the spot is not large enough to contain the whole device, the device can be designed so that it is separated into elements, e.g., electrodes and a stimulator in a cochlear implant, or so that discrete elements are connected, e.g., the pressure sensor and battery in the blood pressure sensor of Frounhofer [36]. The size and shape of the device also affect the delivery method of the device. If the total size of the device is too large for use in insertion tools like a catheter, incision surgery is required for insertion. For the stent-sized medical system, which is smaller than the human organ, a delivery system through minimally invasive surgery should be created or invented. If the device is small enough to fit in a conventional needle size, we can deliver the device by needle injection.

After delivery or implantation of the devices, the human body reacts to the unfamiliar material and starts to attack the material with antibiotics. In this case, neointimal tissue or fibrocellular shields can separate the device from the original tissue. If the device is packaged or encapsulated by material that is not biocompatible, the immune response elicits severe electrical and chemical reactions with the material. Therefore, the biocompatibility of the packaged material has to be confirmed by animal study and good manufacturing practice before implantation.

The human body is an extraordinary environment to the engineer. The new space always has a constant temperature of 36.5℃, is continuously changed by electrical and chemical reactions, and is vulnerable to being extinguished by a tiny modification of a body element. The arcane space should be approached very ethically, logically, and scientifically. In general, medical devices are engineered to restore a body function, to detect a body signal, or to provide mechanical or electrical assistance to a human organ. Therefore, engineers need to acquaint themselves with the human body in terms of environment, functionality, structure, and biological reactions. On the basis of this study, they begin to assemble their knowledge in engineering fields, such as biocompatibility, electronic circuits, micro-electro-mechanical systems, hermeticity or packaging, wireless or wired communications, securities, batteries, insertion tools, and so on. Then, the manufacturing feasibility of a special device has to be checked through modeling and through realistic testing. The manufactured system is tested on the benchtop and put into living things. The manufacturing and testing processes are continued until proper devices are obtained. During those processes, the engineers meet challenges in the following categories: biocompatibility, hermeticity, structural design, delivery system, power management, detection, and wireless communication.

ENGINEER'S CONSIDERTIONS FOR IMPLANTABLE MEDICAL DEVICES

Packaging and Hermeticity

The microelectronic system is operated by electrical connections between electronic components. At the final stage of electronic chip manufacturing, the electronics parts are packaged under a vacuum to prevent degradation of the electrical performance of the components through exposure to the air. Like the microelectronic chip, implantable medical devices need a protective barrier from inner body elements such as cells, proteins, platelets, and chemical gases. Moreover, the packaging has another functionality of trapping the outgas of the inner materials. That is, the packaging should perfectly isolate the inner electrical and mechanical components from the human body environment. If the isolation is airtight, then we can say that the package is hermetically sealed. MIL-STD-883, Method 1014.10, which has been adapted by the medical device industry, provides details of the hermeticity testing procedure. The most common hermeticity measurement is performed by use of a helium leak detector, which is a mass spectrometer designed to analyze helium gas. Fig. 1 shows the helium gas permeability of common medical device materials. The figure also shows the projected lifetimes of the materials as a function of the thickness of the material.

Fig. 1

Material-dependent permeability. The graph shows also permeability as a function of thickness.

The packaging of implantable medical devices is done by use of various materials, such as quartz, fused silica, polymers, metals, and ceramics [56-63]. Packaging of the system encloses the electronic or mechanical system by encapsulation of the polymer and welding or bonding of the metal, glass, and ceramics. Materials of the polymer encapsulation package include epoxies, silicones, polyurethanes, polyimides, silicon-polyimides, parylenes, polycyclic-olefins, silicon-carbons, benzocyclobutenes, and liquid crystal polymers. Silicone rubber has been used for the encapsulation layer for artery line pressure sensors, epoxies have been used to cover the feedthrough connections in ICDs, and polyurethanes have been used to cover platinum wires in the pacemaker. Glass type packages based on quartz, fused silica, and borosilicate are generally completed by melting of the glasses done by local laser-focused heating. The glass packaging method is used for neuromuscular stimulators, radio frequency identification chips, endoscope pills, and implantable blood pressure sensors. The metallic package is the most common hermetic packaging method and is accomplished by laser welding of the metals. The metallic package is applied for loop recorders, pacemakers, ICDs, and cochlear implants.

Structural Design of Implantable Devices and Delivery Systems

The human body is a complex system operated by mechanical, chemical, and electrical mechanisms of numerous organs, tissues, and cells. Furthermore, the system has different shapes, sizes, placement, functionality, and reactions according to age, sex, and race. Therefore, it is difficult to design the whole structure of the medical device at once. Design requires abundant research reviews, mathematical simulations, and benchtop testing with a phantom of the human body, animal studies, and real implants. During the developmental stage, the engineer will meet scientific, biological, and medical impasses. If an electronic device is adequate for handling the electronic data but the chip is too large to insert in the human body, then we should find a substitute electronic chip or totally rework the concept.

In general, actively working implantable devices such as implantable blood pressure measurement devices require an energy source for data processing and wireless communication in battery form. To guarantee the power requirement for the duration of operation, a battery with the proper capacity has to be integrated with the electronic system. However, it is hard to find an appropriate commercial battery. Up to now, finding the battery has been a bottleneck in arterial blood pressure measurement system development. For example, Frounhofer's blood pressure measurement system is assembled with an inner-arterial pressure sensor and an outer-arterial battery.

As mentioned in the previous section, the delivery methods of the devices can be broadly defined as two categories: incision and tools. A review of the literature shows two methods of implantable blood pressure measurements: inner-artery blood pressure measurement and outer-artery blood pressure measurement. Both methods can be described as an implantable direct artery blood pressure measurement, but the measurement spot differs. As shown in Fig. 2, sensors developed by Cong et al. [64] are installed around the artery for good mechanical contact with the artery. This system should be inserted by incision. Another method can be found in a commercialized Cardiomems sensor [17]. As shown in Fig. 2B, the Cardiomems sensor has a rectangular shape with a narrow width and Nitinol springs to fix the sensor in the artery. Cardiomems has a delivery system that uses catheters of 4-5 mm in diameter. In the first stage of development, Cardiomems selected the delivery positions of the sensor, and researchers in the company designed the sensor and delivery system simultaneously.

Fig. 2

Implantable blood pressure sensor. (A) Surgically implanted blood pressure sensor with a cuff-type design. The sensor is installed on the blood vessel directly. (B) Cardiomems implantable blood pressure sensor. The sensor is paced in the target position by use of a delivery system. The sensor is delivered by the same procedure with a stent.

One more thing to consider in device design is the performance of the devices. In general, implantable medical devices are inserted when the patient positively needs the device. In other words, the implantable device is a last hope for the patient. Thus, the performance of the device is the most important factor in the design.

CONCLUSIONS

In this article, considerations in the development of implantable medical devices were reviewed from an engineering viewpoint. By tracing pacemaker development from the first generation of devices in 1958 to current devices, the historical advancement of the medical device was roughly described. There are three participants in the development of medical devices, and gathering information from each of them is crucial. Users demand minimally invasive operations that enable them to be released from a medical facility quickly with lower expense. Medical staffs propose the necessity of the medical device owing to their expertise about the human body in terms of size, functionality, position, and medical approaches. Engineers pour their technical knowledge into the practical design of the devices. They cooperate with medical staff in designing the shape, size, functionality, and method of delivering. Biocompatibility and durability of the material exposed to the inner body environment must be guaranteed by a series of laboratory experiments, animal studies, and so on. Electrical and mechanical devices are hermetically packaged by use of a biocompatible material to establish a perfect barrier between the device and inner body components such as body fluids, cells, and tissues. With the knowledge of advanced technology, structures of the device and the delivery system should be designed by assistance from the user and medical staff. Many simulations, prototypes, and testing help to obtain the best device. The electrical power source is carefully designed to get a suitable shape and the power supply is continuously monitored to ensure uninterrupted operation. For real-time monitoring of the human body, active or passive wireless communication methods are selected with contestation of packaging material, power, and detection interval. Compared with the well-known space, atmospheric, and marine environments, the inner body is an unfamiliar and underdeveloped space to the engineer. Developing medical devices for the human body must be initiated by an understanding of the environment, that is, a human being.

Article information Continued