Vojta Approach Affects Neck Stability and Static Balance in Sitting Position of Children With Hypotonia
Article information
Abstract
Purpose
In this study, the effect of the Vojta approach on neck stability and static balance in children with hypotonia was studied.
Methods
Seventeen children with hypotonia were randomly divided into the Vojta approach group (n=9) and the general physical therapy group (n=8). Each group was applied intervention for 30 minutes per session, 3 times a week, for a total of 4 weeks. Ultrasonography was used to measure deep neck flexor muscle thickness, craniovertebral angle (CVA) to measure neck alignment along the spine segment, and Balancia software program to measure static balance.
Results
In the Vojta approach group, the deep neck flexor muscle thickness was significantly increased (P<0.05), and the CVA was significantly improved (P<0.05). In addition, path area among static balance was significantly improved (P<0.05).
Conclusions
The Vojta approach can be suggested as an effective intervention method for improving neck stability and static balance in children with hypotonia.
• HIGHLIGHTS
- Children with hypotonia reduced gross motor function.
- Low muscle tone affected the posture and reduces the balance in children with hypotonia
- The Vojta approach affected postural improvement by activating the deep spinal muscles.
INTRODUCTION
The Vojta approach is an intervention method that elicits a systemic motor response by stimulating a specific reflex zone in a specific starting position [1]. Stimulating the reflex zone of the Vojta approach inhibits abnormal movements and induces normal motor development by repeatedly remembering normal movements in the brain [2]. In addition, since it has a certain direction of muscle contraction, it stimulates muscles, joints, ligaments, and tendons, and postural maintenance can be improved through isometric contraction [3]. Based on this purpose, the Vojta approach has been applied to various diseases such as children with developmental delay (DD) [1], stroke patients [4], and musculoskeletal diseases [5].
Children who present with weakness, low muscle tone, abnormal reflexes, and sensory and motor problems have developmental delays and are considered hypotonia [6]. They are sometimes accompanied with seizures and organ malformation [7,8]. Many disorders, including neurological disorders, endocrine and metabolic disorders, Prader-Willi syndrome, and spinal muscular atrophy, often present with hypotonia as a clinical symptom [6]. Hypotonia is characterized by lack of resistance to passive movements, joint hypermobility, and reduced endurance [8,9]. This causes abnormalities in the posture of tilting the head back in a sitting position, and excessive wrinkles appear on the neck, which lowers the stability of the neck [10,11].
Neck stability refers to the action of the deep neck flexor muscle, the antigravity flexor muscle that controls the head movement [11]. The deep neck flexor muscles have a positive effect on the correct alignment of the neck and the balance of the trunk and neck and play a role in providing neck stability during movement [12,13]. They are attached directly to the cervical spine and joints and play an important role in the postural control of the cervical spine and each segment stability [14]. Weak deep neck flexor muscle can lead to cervical spine instability [12]. This problem causes the forward head posture (FHP), which affects balance due to incorrect afferent input from the neck muscles [15].
Balance is the basis of motor development, and tonic activation of the trunk muscles is necessary to maintain an upright sitting posture [16,17]. Hypotonia are difficult to maintain balance due to low muscle tone, and postural sway are greater than those of typical developing children [18]. Abnormal posture is a major factor that reduces balance ability and quality of life [19,20], and balance disorders affect daily life by limiting interactions with the environment [21]. Therefore, it is important to improve balance in children with hypotonia.
Various interventions such as treadmill, dual task, neck and trunk stabilization exercise, and Vojta approach have been applied to improve motor function [1,9,15,22,23]. Among them, the Vojta approach has been reported to influence postural improvement by activating the deep spinal muscles [3]. Studies on the Vojta approach mainly focuses on children with hypertonia, and there are few studies on children with hypotonia. In addition, the neck stability and balance in children with hypotonia are decreased, but studies on this ae rare. Therefore, we determined the effect of the Vojta approach on neck stability and static balance in sitting position in children with hypotonia.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Participants
The experiment was performed on children with hypotonia who were admitted to hospital. Th inclusion criteria were as follows: (1) children diagnosed with DD before the age of 5 and accompanied by hypotonia, (2) gross motor function classification system level II–IV, (3) children who can perform simple verbal instructions from the researcher, (4) children who can maintain a sitting posture. The exclusion criteria were as follows: (1) children with DD accompanied by spasticity, (2) children with vision and hearing impairments, (3) children with uncontrolled seizure, (4) children with acute fever or inflammation. All participants were informed of the study and signed consent forms. This study was conducted after approval by the Research Ethics Committee of the Kyungnam University (1040460-A-2020-016).
Participants were divided into 2 groups (experimental group and control group). The general characteristics of the participants were as follows: experimental group (n=9), age 46.88± 20.39 months, gross motor function classification system (GMFCS) I/II/III/IV=1/2/4/2 and control group (n=8), age 54.87± 19.09 months, GMFCS I/II/III/IV=1/2/3/2. The experimental group applied the Vojta approach, and the control group applied general physical therapy. Intervention was applied to each group for 30 minutes per session, twice a day, 3 times a week, for a total of 4 weeks. All groups were examined for deep neck flexor muscle thickness, craniovertebral angle (CVA), static balance before and after intervention.
Intervention
The Vojta approach is divided into reflex turning 1, reflex turning 2, reflex creeping, and first position. The reflex turning 1 stimulated the breast zone in the supine position, and reflex turning 2 stimulated the medial border of the scapula and the anterior superior iliac spine (ASIS) in the side lying position. Reflex creeping stimulated the medial epicondyle of the humerus and calcaneus in the prone position. In the first position, both knees bent in the prone position, and the upper limbs were in the same position as the reflex creeping, stimulating the ASIS and the medial epicondyle of the humerus. Each posture was applied for a total of 30 minutes, 10 minutes each, and reflex creeping or the first position was selected according to the characteristics of the child.
Ultrasonography
The thicknesses of deep neck flexor muscle were scanned images in B mode using SONON application, and a 10-MHz linear probe of ultrasonography (Sonson, Healcerion, Seoul, Korea). Participants were seated with their feet on the floor, with the spine extended and maintained as far as possible. The probe was placed vertically at a position 3 cm outward from the center of the trachea to measure the thickness of the right deep neck flexor muscle [24]. It was measured at the end of the exhalation to reduce the error due to respiration. For the thickness of the muscle, a baseline was determined between the cervical spine 4 and 5, and then 3 lines were drawn at 0.5 cm intervals to measure the length, and the average value of 6 lines for 2 images was used. The deep neck flexor muscle thickness was measured by NIH Image J ver. 1.47 (Sun Microsystems Inc., Stapleton, NY, USA) (Fig. 1).
Ultrasonography imaging of the deep neck flexor muscle in children with hypotonia. The deep neck flexor muscle thickness was measured in a sitting position with the back as straight as possible. A baseline was established between cervical vertebra 4 and 5, and 3 lines were drawn at 0.5-cm intervals to measure the length.
Craniovertebral Angle
To measure CVA, the examiner asked the child to remain in a sitting position and stare straight ahead. We installed and recorded Galaxy Tab S3 (Samsung, Seoul, Korea) at 3-m distance and a 0.7-m height on the right side of the child to measure the CVA according to each segment. CVA was measured when supporting 5 segments of the spine: thoracic spine 3 (T3), T7, T11, lumbar spine 3 (L3), sacral spine (S1). Eight small round stickers (2 cm×2 cm×2 cm) were attached to C7, T3, T7, T11, L3, S1, ear tragus, temporal lobe sulcus to accurately track the vertebral segment and CVA. CVA measured the angle formed by the horizontal line passing through the spinous process of C7 and the line connecting C7 and ear tragus [25]. The angle was measured according to the segment using the Dartfish software program (Dartfish 7, Lausanne, Switzerland). The reliability for the CVA is 0.88 [25].
Static Balance
To measure the static balance in the sitting position, center of pressure information for the X and Y axes was collected using a Wii Balance Board (Nintendo, Kyoto, Japan). The collected data were measured for path length, path velocity and path area using Balancia software version 2.0 (Minto Systems, Seoul, Korea). Participants were seated on a Wii balance board at the height of the feet not touching the floor, with their arms relaxed and gazing straight ahead. They kept their eyes open for 20 seconds and were measured twice and the average value was used.
Date Analysis
IBM SPSS version 21.0 (IBM Corp., Armonk, NY, USA) was used for statistical analysis. Shapiro-Wilks test was performed to test the normality of variables. We used the independent t-test for differences between groups and the paired t-test for difference within group. All levels of statistical significance (α) were set to 0.05.
RESULTS
Comparison of Deep Neck Flexor Muscle Thickness
In the experimental and control group, there was a significant difference within group (P<0.05) (Table 1).
Comparison of deep neck flexor muscle thickness (cm)
Comparison of CVA
T7, T11, L3, and S1 were significantly different between the groups in postintervention (P <0.05). In the experimental group, there was a significant difference within the group in T7, T11, L3, and S1 (P<0.05). The change (post-pre) in T11, L3, and S1 was significantly different between the groups (P<0.05) (Table 2).
Comparison of CVA in sitting position (˚)
DISCUSSION
Children with hypotonia show delayed motor development [6]. The Vojta approach allows the body to be erected and postural control through tonic muscle contraction of the neck, trunk, and limbs [4].
In this study, the thickness of the deep neck flexor muscle and the CVA were increased in the Vojta approach group. Low muscle tone of the trunk in children with hypotonia increases the bending of the lumbar spine in the sitting position and affects the kyphosis of the thoracic spine [6]. This leads to postural misalignment, which causes FHP and ultimately reduces quality of life [9,19]. The FHP reduces the CVA in the sitting position and causes deep neck flexor muscle weakness [26]. The deep neck flexor muscle is interconnected with the deep muscles of the spine located below the cervical spine, and the instability of the vertebral segment eventually affects the instability of the cervical spine [27]. Ishida et al. [26] reported a correlation between deep neck flexor muscle and CVA in healthy people, as the FHP does not use the deep neck flexor muscle in a sitting position, resulting in a smaller thickness of the deep neck flexor muscle. Falla et al. [14] reported that craniocervical training improved the upright posture of the cervical spine when craniocervical training and endurance strength training of deep neck flexion muscles were applied to patients with chronic neck pain. This is a result of a direct improvement of the deep neck flexors of the cervical spine, and inadequate control of the head was functionally related to deep cervical muscle damage. Kang et al. [28] found that when scapular stabilization exercise was applied to FHP patients, SCM activity decreased and CVA increased. This increased the activation of muscles scapular around the scapula, which affected the entire upper body and improved the round shoulder and spine alignment. Previous studies show that when the deep neck flexor muscle thickens, CVA increases, and the posture of the spine also affects neck alignment. In this study, it is thought that deep neck flexor muscle stimulation and spinal extension through reflex creeping of the Vojta approach activated deep spinal muscles. In addition, it is thought that the increase in the thickness of the deep neck flexor muscle improved the CVA by increasing the stability of the spine. The CVA was improved when supporting all vertebral segments except T3 in the experimental group, and these results suggest that stimulation of the deep spinal muscles also affects the posture of the cervical spine.
The misalignment of the body makes it difficult to control the head and trunk in a sitting or standing position and causes problems with balance and postural control [29]. Children with hypotonia have decreased flexibility due to hypotonia and lack of motivation, resulting in increased postural sway than typical developmental children [30]. Therefore, reduction of postural sway in children with hypotonia can be the goal of intervention. Shin et al. [15] reported that the static balance improved when a neck and trunk stabilization exercise was applied to children with spastic CP. This is a result of the improvement of trunk and neck muscle strength, they mentioned that the balance was improved by integrating sensory information in the central nervous system to perform movement. Park et al. [31] reported that when postural control training in a sitting position using virtual reality for children with spasticity, balance ability improved in the sitting position. In this study, path area among the static balance was improved in the Vojta approach group. These results suggest that the tonic muscle contraction through the Vojta approach improved afferent information of the neck, affecting neck stability and static balance. However, the path velocity and path length were not significantly different from those of the general physical therapy group, which is thought to be due to the role of visual information monitoring the body position when looking straight ahead to maintain a sitting posture and the short duration of intervention.
Summarizing the results of this study, the vertebral muscles strengthened through the Vojta approach influenced the increase in the thickness of the deep neck flexors, thereby improving the stability of the neck, which increased CVA. In addition, the improvement of afferent information through neck stability influenced the static balance. Therefore, the Vojta approach can be suggested as an effective intervention for improving neck stability and balance in children with hypotonia. The limitation of this study is that it is difficult to generalize the contents because the number of participants is small and the intervention period is short. In addition to experimental interventions, participants had difficulty controlling variables in their daily lives. Therefore, future research should be conducted to supplement these limitations.
Notes
Research Ethics
This study was conducted after approval by the Research Ethics Committee of Kyungnam University (1040460-A-2020-016).
Conflict of Interest
No potential conflict of interest relevant to this article was reported.
AUTHOR CONTRIBUTION STATEMENT
·Conceptualization: SYH
·Data curation: SYH
·Formal analysis: SYH
·Funding acquisition: YHS
·Methodology: SYH
·Project administration: YHS
·Visualization: YHS
·Writing-original draft: YHS
·Writing-review & editing: YHS